There was a recent Facebook video of a newly graduated nurse practitioner in tears, returning from her night shift on the COVID-19 unit. She is sobbing and explains she just “coded someone two years older than me, and they died.” Her grief is unmistakable. Death of a young patient is not a common experience for most practitioners, let alone someone new to practice. The onslaught and volume of critical patients (of all ages) resulting in death is beyond what most providers have ever contemplated as part of care.
The coronavirus outbreak of 2020 caught nearly everyone off guard. But no one is feeling its effects quite like frontline healthcare workers. While the mental health impact of pandemics is not widely studied, research suggests that frontline healthcare workers are experiencing higher levels of depression, anxiety and post-traumatic stress.
Along with experiencing greater acuity in patients, as well as death and dying, frontline healthcare workers are concerned with their own well being and exposure to the virus, as well as how it impacts their loved ones at home. In some cases, they are practicing with insufficient PPE. Additionally, constantly changing information and protocols are difficult to keep up with, and this leave clinicians worried about whether they are using best practices for their patients. Uncertainty about the future health of their patients, their own practice and their institution is another concern. In some states, lack of critical care beds, medical equipment and staffing has left clinicians in a position of needing to determine who gets care and who does not.
For those not on the frontline, there is stress of decreased workloads, furloughs, changes to the delivery of care, and even guilt feelings related to their role in “fighting” the pandemic.
Moral injury is a term originally applied to veterans of war caused by “perpetrating, failing to prevent, bearing witness to acts that ultimately transgress one’s deeply held moral beliefs,” creating dissonance. The term has more recently been ascribed to physicians when faced with the need to let business and financial decisions influence delivery of patient care. During a pandemic healthcare workers on the front lines may also feel responsible for the death of others where impossible choices need to be made about distribution of life-sustaining equipment, and where life and death decisions need to be made with ever changing guidelines for treating the virus.
Compassion fatigue is an extreme state of tension and preoccupation with the suffering of those being helped to the degree that it can create a secondary traumatic stress for the helper. Whereas with burnout, physicians may find they “detach” from patients, with compassion fatigue, emotional connection continues to the point of distress for the physician.
Various factors can determine the impact of COVID-19 on practitioners, including:
It may seem like these recommendations are too simple or obvious to make a difference, but we know that these avenues for self-care can be a significant deterrent to stress, compassion fatigue, burnout and post-traumatic stress.
As part of your Physician Well Being Resources, you have access to Peer Coaching, in-the-moment behavioral health support, face-to-face or virtual counseling, a concierge service to help with work/life balance and much more. These resources can help you explore, understand and manage your feelings of stress, anxiety, burnout and compassion fatigue related to your experiences during COVID-19. Contact us at 877.731.3949 or through the VITAL WorkLife App to access your resources.
If you are interested in learning more about our proactive solutions to support the well being of your physicians and advanced practitioners, contact us online.
Sources:
https://www.jwatch.org/na51190/2020/03/27/mental-health-effects-covid-19-healthcare-workers-china
Litz BT, Stein N, Delaney E, et al.: Moral injury and moral repair in war veterans: a preliminary model and intervention strategy. Clin Psychol Rev 2009; 29:695–706 Crossref, Google Scholar
https://www.statnews.com/2018/07/26/physicians-not-burning-out-they-are-suffering-moral-injury/
Tulane University professor Charles R. Figley, MD, whose 1995 book on the topic essentially founded the study of workplace stress among human services providers.